How the seven disciplines fit together
The Generation of Knowledge
How knowledge is created, tested, shared and trusted.
The Generation of Knowledge is ModQu's name for how the seven disciplines work together: a question is asked, evidence is collected and tested, and the result becomes knowledge that people can rely on.
These articles look at knowledge itself: what it is, how it has been produced through history, how organisations create and manage it, and how it is trusted, valued and shared.
Epistemology9 articles
- What Is Knowledge? Justified True Belief and Its Challenges
The classic definition of knowledge as justified true belief, where it comes from, why a three-page paper in 1963 unsettled it, and what the debate means for anyone who produces evidence for decisions.
5 min read - The Gettier Problem and the Definition of Knowledge
How Edmund Gettier's counterexamples broke the classical definition of knowledge, the sixty-year search for a fourth condition, and what the problem of epistemic luck teaches anyone who relies on evidence.
6 min read - Foundationalism, Coherentism and the Structure of Knowledge
Does knowledge rest on secure foundations, or is it a web of beliefs that support one another? The regress problem, the main theories of epistemic structure, and what they imply for building a trustworthy body of evidence.
11 min read - Testimony as a Source of Knowledge
Most of what we know we were told by someone else. This article explains how philosophers have tried to justify trust in testimony, what psychology shows about when people believe others, and why every survey is a form of testimony.
7 min read - Knowledge From Many Voices: The Epistemology of Aggregated Opinion
When can combining many people's judgements produce knowledge that none of them holds alone? The conditions behind the "wisdom of crowds", and why independence and diversity matter more than numbers.
3 min read - Social Epistemology: Knowledge as a Collective Achievement
Most knowledge is produced, checked and held by groups, not by isolated individuals. This article explains social epistemology, from trust and the division of cognitive labour to group belief, diversity and communication networks, and what it means for organisations that generate knowledge.
13 min read - Tacit and Explicit Knowledge: Polanyi's Distinction
Michael Polanyi's claim that "we can know more than we can tell", how it was developed by management theorists and sociologists, what research shows about knowledge that resists being written down, and how organisations can work with it.
8 min read - Know-How Versus Know-That
Gilbert Ryle's distinction between knowing facts and knowing how to do things, the modern debate over whether it holds, what memory research adds, and why research organisations need both kinds of knowledge.
4 min read - The Limits of Knowledge and the Role of Uncertainty
Why all empirical knowledge is uncertain, the different kinds of uncertainty that researchers face, how people misjudge what they know, and how honest treatment of uncertainty makes knowledge more useful, not less.
10 min read
History of knowledge8 articles
- The History of Knowledge Production From Antiquity to Today
A short history of how societies have organised the making of knowledge, from ancient libraries and medieval universities to print, scientific societies, research universities, big science and the digital era.
4 min read - The Library of Alexandria and the Ancient Organisation of Knowledge
What we actually know about the Library of Alexandria, how its scholars collected, edited and catalogued the written knowledge of their world, why the story of its single fiery destruction is a myth, and what it still teaches about organising knowledge.
3 min read - The Printing Press and the Knowledge Revolution
How movable-type printing changed the production, checking and spread of knowledge in early modern Europe, what economic historians have measured about its effects, and why historians still debate what kind of revolution it was.
10 min read - The Scientific Revolution and the Birth of Modern Knowledge
How sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Europe developed new ways of producing knowledge about nature, based on observation, experiment, mathematics and public scrutiny, and why historians still debate what the "Scientific Revolution" was.
6 min read - The Encyclopédie and the Enlightenment Project
How Diderot and d'Alembert's Encyclopédie tried to map and share all human knowledge, how it classified the sciences and the trades, how it survived censorship, and what its ambitions still mean for anyone who organises knowledge for others.
8 min read - The Royal Society and the Institutionalisation of Science
How a small group of seventeenth-century London gentlemen created an institution for testing and publishing claims about nature, and how its practices of witnessing, registering, publishing and refereeing became the infrastructure of modern research.
5 min read - The Rise of the Research University
How the university changed from a place that transmitted established learning into an engine of new knowledge, from Berlin in 1810 to the American graduate school and the post-war research system, and what that model means today.
4 min read - The Information Age and the Knowledge Society
How economists and sociologists came to describe modern societies as information or knowledge societies, the evidence for and against the idea, how the digital revolution changed the scale of information, and the new problems of attention, inequality and trust it created.
9 min read
Knowledge production18 articles
- Mode 1 and Mode 2 Knowledge Production
What Gibbons and colleagues meant by Mode 1 and Mode 2 knowledge production, the five features they used to define the new mode, the criticisms the idea has faced, and what it implies for organisations that produce applied research.
10 min read - The Triple Helix: Universities, Industry and Government
The triple helix model of innovation, in which universities, industry and government interact and take on parts of each other's roles, its later extensions, its criticisms, and what it suggests about how useful knowledge is produced.
3 min read - How New Knowledge Is Created: From Data to Wisdom
The processes by which people and organisations turn observations into data, data into information, information into knowledge and knowledge into wise action, including induction, abduction, testing and sensemaking, and the places where each step can go wrong.
6 min read - The DIKW Pyramid: Data, Information, Knowledge, Wisdom
Where the data-information-knowledge-wisdom hierarchy came from, what each level means, how it applies to survey research, and why its critics argue the pyramid should also be read from the top down.
12 min read - Discovery Versus Invention in the Growth of Knowledge
The difference between discovering what already exists and inventing what did not, why historians and philosophers find the line hard to draw, how both grow knowledge, and why the distinction matters for applied research.
8 min read - Serendipity in the Generation of Knowledge
What serendipity means, famous cases from penicillin to the cosmic microwave background, why chance discoveries depend on prepared minds and supportive organisations, how serendipity has been classified and studied, and how research teams can make room for the unexpected without fooling themselves.
13 min read - Cumulative Knowledge: Standing on the Shoulders of Giants
How knowledge builds on earlier knowledge, from the medieval image of dwarfs on the shoulders of giants to citation networks and meta-analysis, why accumulation is getting harder, how it breaks down, and how research organisations can build on what is already known.
7 min read - Interdisciplinary Research and the Creation of New Fields
What multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research mean, how new fields such as psychology, molecular biology and survey methodology were formed at the boundaries of older ones, what the evidence says about the costs and benefits of crossing disciplines, and how to make interdisciplinary teams work.
13 min read - Citizen-Generated Knowledge
How members of the public contribute to research, from counting birds and classifying galaxies to challenging experts with local knowledge, the levels at which they can take part, the evidence on data quality, the ethical questions involved, and what citizen science means for organisations that gather information from the public.
7 min read - Crowdsourcing Knowledge: Wikipedia and Beyond
How crowdsourcing produces knowledge, from Wikipedia to open innovation contests and online research panels, what the evidence says about its accuracy, the coordination and diversity problems it faces, and what it teaches about combining many contributions into reliable knowledge.
5 min read - Primary Data as the Raw Material of Knowledge
What primary data are, how they differ from secondary, administrative and "found" data, why data are never simply raw, what designed data offer that big data cannot, and how to collect primary data that can bear the weight of the knowledge built on them.
12 min read - Surveys as Engines of Knowledge Generation
How the sample survey became one of the most productive methods for generating knowledge about people and societies, the scientific foundations that make it work, the four kinds of knowledge it produces, the errors that threaten it, and how surveys are adapting to falling response rates and new data sources.
12 min read - The Lifecycle of Knowledge from Collection to Use
The stages through which research knowledge passes, from planning and collection to analysis, sharing, use, preservation and eventual revision, and the points in that lifecycle where value is most often lost.
4 min read - How Measurement Choices Shape What Can Be Known
How decisions about concepts, indicators, scales and question wording determine what research can find, the ideas of reliability and validity used to judge measures, how measures change the behaviour they measure, and how to make measurement choices deliberately and transparently.
9 min read - The Difference Between Discovering, Interpreting, and Deciding
Why finding out what is the case, working out what it means and choosing what to do are different activities with different standards, how they become confused, where values legitimately enter, and how research organisations can keep the three distinct while connecting them.
12 min read - Integrating Surveys, Research, and Statistics into a Coherent Evidence Base
How to combine survey results, qualitative research, published studies, administrative records and statistical models into a single body of evidence, using triangulation, mixed methods, systematic review, data linkage and explicit judgements of strength, so that decisions rest on the whole of what is known.
9 min read - From Inquiry and Investigation to Defensible Knowledge
How inquiry and investigation turn questions into conclusions that can withstand challenge, using the structure of argument, the weighing of evidence, alternative explanations, pre-specified methods and full records.
5 min read - Intelligence and Insights as Bridges Between Evidence and Action
How intelligence and insight work connect evidence to decisions, from the intelligence cycle and key intelligence topics to the language of probability, forecasting accuracy and the conditions under which insights can be trusted.
7 min read
Knowledge management7 articles
- Knowledge Management: Concepts and Practice
What knowledge management means, the core processes it covers, the choice between codifying knowledge and connecting people, why knowledge is hard to move inside organisations, and what makes knowledge management work in practice.
4 min read - Nonaka's SECI Model of Organisational Knowledge Creation
Ikujiro Nonaka's model of how organisations create knowledge through socialisation, externalisation, combination and internalisation, the idea of ba as a shared space for knowledge creation, the main criticisms of the model and how it can be applied in research work.
8 min read - The Knowledge-Creating Company
What it means for a company to create knowledge rather than merely process information, drawing on Nonaka and Takeuchi, theories of organisational learning, the knowledge-based view of the firm, and research on the routines, cultures and structures that help or hinder organisational learning.
11 min read - Communities of Practice
What communities of practice are, how newcomers learn by participating in them, how organisations have tried to cultivate them, the evidence on their value, the criticisms of the concept, and how research teams can use it to share skill and judgement.
9 min read - Organisational Memory and Knowledge Loss
How organisations remember, where their memory is held, how quickly knowledge gained from experience can fade, why knowledge leaves with people, and practical ways to keep what an organisation has learned.
9 min read - Knowledge Transfer Between Organisations
How knowledge moves between organisations through alliances, networks, people and supply chains, what makes transfer succeed or fail, and what research organisations can learn from the evidence.
7 min read - Absorptive Capacity: How Firms Learn From External Knowledge
What absorptive capacity is, why an organisation's ability to learn from outside depends on what it already knows, how the concept has been refined and measured, what builds it, and what it means for organisations that produce and use research.
12 min read
Knowledge economy9 articles
- The Knowledge Economy: Concepts and Measurement
Where the idea of a knowledge economy came from, what economists mean by it, how its size and growth are measured through research spending, skills, patents and intangible investment, and the limits of those measures.
11 min read - Knowledge as a Competitive Advantage
Why knowledge can give a firm an advantage over its rivals, what makes that advantage last, how it can turn into rigidity, and what this means for firms that rely on research and data.
5 min read - Intellectual Capital and Intangible Assets
What intellectual capital and intangible assets are, how they are divided into human, structural and relational capital, why accounting struggles to record them, how researchers and firms have tried to measure them and what the evidence says about their value.
9 min read - Information Asymmetry and the Value of Knowledge in Markets
How unequal knowledge between buyers and sellers shapes markets, from Akerlof's market for lemons to signalling, screening, reputation and disclosure, and why independent, trustworthy information has economic value.
12 min read - The Economics of Information: Knowledge as a Public Good
Why economists describe knowledge as a public good, what follows for how much knowledge markets produce, how patents, public funding and open science respond to the problem, and what it means for data and research.
8 min read - Data as an Asset: Valuing Information
Whether data can be treated as an asset, why its value is hard to measure, the main methods for valuing information, from cost and market approaches to the expected value of information in decisions, and what makes data more or less valuable.
11 min read - The Market for Data and Research Products
How the market for data and research is organised, from custom and syndicated research to analytics and data brokers, how such products are priced, how buyers judge quality and how the market is changing.
7 min read - Data Marketplaces and the Commercialisation of Knowledge
How knowledge and data are turned into products and traded, what data marketplaces are and why many struggle, the problems of pricing, trust and privacy they must solve, and the rules and models that are shaping how data are shared and sold.
12 min read - Information Goods: Pricing and Selling Knowledge
Why information goods cannot be priced like ordinary products, and how sellers of knowledge use value-based pricing, versioning, bundling, subscriptions, free samples and reputation to sell reports, data and research.
7 min read
Knowledge and decisions7 articles
- Evidence-Based Management
What evidence-based management is, where it came from, the four sources of evidence it draws on, the steps it involves, the obstacles that keep managers from using evidence and how organisations can make better use of research and data in their decisions.
8 min read - Decision-Making Under Uncertainty
How decisions can be made when the future is uncertain, from the difference between risk and uncertainty and the theory of expected utility to the heuristics and biases that shape real choices, levels of uncertainty and practical tools such as scenarios and robust strategies.
5 min read - The Value of Information in Decision Theory
How decision theory measures the value of information, from Bayesian updating and the expected value of perfect and sample information to choosing the size of a study, with applications in health, environment and business research.
6 min read - Knowledge, Power and Who Gets to Know
How power shapes the production and use of knowledge, from the questions asked and the people counted to who interprets and who has access, with evidence on statistics and the state, gaps in data, epistemic injustice and practices that spread the power to know more fairly.
10 min read - Democratisation of Knowledge in the Digital Era
Whether digital technology has made knowledge more widely available, produced and shared, examining open access, open data, wikis, citizen science and online courses, the persistence of digital divides, the spread of misinformation and what it all means for trustworthy evidence.
7 min read - Knowledge Gaps: How to Identify and Prioritize What Is Unknown
What knowledge gaps are, the different kinds of ignorance, systematic ways to find gaps through reviews and evidence maps, why research effort is often wasted on the wrong questions, and practical methods for deciding which gaps to fill first.
13 min read - Uncertainty, Probability, and Confidence Across Statistical, Intelligence, and Investigative Knowledge
How statisticians, intelligence analysts, investigators and courts each express uncertainty, what confidence intervals, estimative language, confidence levels and standards of proof really mean, the common errors in reading them and how to communicate uncertainty clearly across fields.
8 min read
Trust, quality and the future16 articles
- Trust in Knowledge: Expertise, Authority and Credibility
Why most of what anyone knows rests on trust in others, how non-experts can judge experts, what makes a source credible, why trust in expertise divides along group lines, and how producers of knowledge can earn trust that is deserved.
6 min read - Post-Truth and the Crisis of Shared Knowledge
What the term post-truth describes, how misinformation spreads and why corrections often struggle, the role of motivated reasoning and polarisation, what the evidence says about how serious the problem is, and what producers of knowledge can do to rebuild a shared basis of fact.
11 min read - Filter Bubbles and Fragmented Knowledge
What filter bubbles and echo chambers are, what large studies of online news exposure have found, why the evidence is more mixed than popular accounts suggest, and what the fragmentation of audiences means for shared knowledge and for research.
6 min read - Information Literacy as a Foundation for Knowledge
What information literacy means, how the idea developed from library skills to a framework for critical thinking about sources, what research shows about how people actually evaluate information, the methods that work, and why information literacy matters for anyone who produces or uses research.
10 min read - Peer Review, Verification and Quality Control of Knowledge
How peer review developed, what evidence shows about its strengths and weaknesses, why it cannot catch every error, and how replication, data checking, preregistration, correction and professional standards add further layers of quality control for research of every kind.
10 min read - Ethics of Knowledge Generation: Consent, Fairness and Benefit
The ethical principles that govern research with people, how they arose from past abuses, and what consent, fairness and benefit mean in practice for surveys, market research and other knowledge-generating work.
4 min read - Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Knowledge Production
How artificial intelligence is changing the production of knowledge, from scientific discovery to survey research, the risks it brings, including fabricated content and illusions of understanding, and the human checks that remain essential.
3 min read - Machine-Generated Knowledge: Can AI Know Anything?
Whether artificial intelligence systems can be said to know anything, examined through the classic conditions for knowledge, the debate over machine understanding, the problem of opacity, the evidence on how reliable AI outputs are, and what the answer means for people who use machine-generated claims.
12 min read - Knowledge Graphs and Machine-Readable Knowledge
What knowledge graphs are, how they grew from semantic networks and the semantic web, how ontologies, linked data and open projects such as Wikidata work, what knowledge graphs offer and where they fall short, and how they can make survey and statistical knowledge easier to find, combine and reuse.
10 min read - Preserving Knowledge for the Future: Archives and Digital Preservation
Why knowledge is lost, how archival thinking developed, why digital information is more fragile than it seems, the models and practices used to preserve it, the evidence on disappearing data and links, and how research organisations can keep their data and findings usable for decades.
11 min read - Modern Queries: Asking the Right Questions to Generate New Knowledge
Why the question comes before the answer in every inquiry, how a vague concern becomes an answerable research question, the costly error of answering the wrong question, and how good survey questions turn a research question into evidence.
5 min read - The Generation of Knowledge: Surveys, Research, Statistics, Intelligence, Insights, Inquiry and Investigation as One System
How seven disciplines, inquiry, research, surveys, statistics, investigation, intelligence and insights, each contribute a distinct step to the generation of knowledge, how they depend on one another, and why treating them as one system produces more reliable knowledge than treating them apart.
5 min read - Documentation as Infrastructure for Trustworthy Knowledge
Why documentation is the hidden infrastructure on which trustworthy knowledge depends, what happens when it is missing, the standards and tools that support it in research, statistics and data science, and how research organisations can document their work so that findings can be checked, reused and trusted.
10 min read - Transparency, Provenance, and the Traceability of Knowledge
What transparency and provenance mean for knowledge, how the ability to trace a claim back to its sources protects against error and distortion, what happens when citations drift from their sources, the standards that support traceability, and how research organisations can make their findings traceable.
8 min read - Ethical Governance of Knowledge Generation in Survey, Research, and Intelligence Contexts
How the ethics of generating knowledge about people is governed in practice across survey and market research, academic and public research, and intelligence work, covering ethics review, data protection, professional codes, oversight of intelligence, the limits of anonymisation, Indigenous data governance and the new challenges of big data and artificial intelligence.
12 min read - Communication and Dissemination Strategies for Knowledge Generated Through the Seven Disciplines
How to communicate and disseminate knowledge produced through inquiry, research, surveys, statistics, investigation, intelligence and insights, covering the questions every dissemination plan must answer, layered reporting, presenting numbers and uncertainty, effective charts and the conditions under which decision-makers actually use evidence.
5 min read
Other disciplines
Explore the other disciplines
Inquiry
The art of asking good questions and reasoning carefully toward answers.
Insights
What makes a finding useful, and how teams turn data into decisions.
Surveys
How surveys are designed, sampled, fielded and checked, from the first questionnaires to online panels.
Research
The methods and standards behind sound research, from study design to reporting the results.
Statistics
The numbers behind the findings: describing data, testing ideas and reading results correctly.
Intelligence
Turning scattered information into knowledge an organisation can act on.
Investigation
Methods for establishing facts in business, markets, science and public life.
The Generation of Knowledge
How knowledge is created, tested, shared and trusted.